|
Services: Knowledge Portals · Knowledge Map · Knowledge Network · Book of Knowledge · NEWS· INFORMATION
Channels: General Business · Business Technology · E-Business · Knowledge Management Community: Join the Network! · Global Network · Events Calendar · Executive Jobs |
|
Posted by Kees de Vos on July 26, 1999 at 10:18:47:
In Reply to: Knowledge vs. Information: a clean start to the debate below. posted by John Bardos on July 25, 1999 at 15:08:44:
Hi John,
in my opinion everybody is entitled to their own set of definitions. Based on my experiences the one that works best for me is:
- Knowledge can only be stored in the minds of people, everything else is therefore data or information. Explicit knowledge is "nothing more" than information!
- The difference between information and data is a bit more blurry, it depends on the context it is used for. However in the situations I encountered this difference is not really significant.
The bottomline is that for knowledge to flow, emphasising on the data or information (books, manuals, intranet, etc., etc., etc.) alone will just not do.
When one person shares his/her knowledge what gets transferred is information. This information will ALWAYS be interpreted by the receiver of this information, hereby creating knowledge at the end of the receiver. Whether this knowledge is actually contributing to the referential framework of the receiver depends on it being accepted or not. If I send the knowledge I have using the wrong words/intonation/medium, it might be rejected by the receiver. Mind you, there still tends to be knowledge created at the part of the receiver. If I keep up this wrong line of communication, the knowledge created at the end of the receiver might well be not to even bother assessing it at all.
As knowledge itself is only present in the heads of individuals I see Knowledge Management as a communication issue, which end tends to be to align the goals of both the individuals in an organization and the goals of the organization as a whole.
Again, this one works best for me. It being MY personal "truth/knowledge" I can only hope this explanation will be fruitful to others :-)
Kees de Vos
- A picture says more than a thousand words :-) Kees de Vos 20:42:10 7/29/99 (0)
- Re: Knowledge vs. Information Mezei 13:12:09 7/27/99 (2)
- Re: Knowledge vs. Information John Tieso 14:03:30 8/02/99 (0)
- Tacit information? John Bardos 17:59:12 7/27/99 (0)
- Explicit - Knowledge a description of presentation? Boris Pluskowski 09:57:41 7/27/99 (68)
- Re: Explicit - Knowledge a description of presentation? P. Richard Hansen 10:20:21 7/29/99 (63)
- Knowledge, Format and Quality Martyn R Jones 17:51:55 8/01/99 (4)
- Re: Knowledge, Format and Quality P. Richard Hansen 20:05:39 8/02/99 (3)
- Absurdity and Cliff Faces Boris 06:20:56 8/04/99 (0)
- Jones The Absurd Martyn R Jones 04:57:50 8/03/99 (1)
- Re: Jones The Absurd (and Eclectic) Kees de Vos 09:17:56 8/04/99 (0)
- Re: Explicit - Knowledge a description of presentation? Reilly Atkinson 17:10:37 8/01/99 (0)
- Re: Explicit - Knowledge a description of presentation? Boris 08:36:07 7/30/99 (56)
- Re: Explicit - Knowledge a description of presentation? P. Richard Hansen 10:29:03 7/30/99 (55)
- Re: Explicit - Knowledge a description of presentation? Reilly Atkinson 22:06:16 8/01/99 (1)
- Re: Explicit - Knowledge a description of presentation? Reilly Atkinson 00:31:19 8/02/99 (0)
- Et tu.. Kees de Vos 19:47:19 7/30/99 (52)
- Re: Et tu.. Boris 07:27:40 8/02/99 (51)
- Re: knowledge transferrence by writing Boris 07:33:26 8/02/99 (50)
- Re: knowledge transferrence by writing - another! Boris 06:48:58 8/04/99 (29)
- Re: knowledge transferrence by writing - another! Kees de Vos 08:16:39 8/04/99 (28)
- Re: knowledge transferrence by writing - another! boris 11:25:10 8/04/99 (27)
- Storytelling - The Tribal Chief Kees de Vos 12:04:22 8/04/99 (26)
- Re: Storytelling - The Tribal Chief boris 07:55:07 8/10/99 (25)
- Can knowledge be wrong? Kees de Vos 14:19:14 8/10/99 (24)
- Re: Can knowledge be wrong? Daan de Koning 18:40:23 8/16/99 (23)
- Re: Can knowledge be wrong? Kees de Vos 04:41:32 8/18/99 (22)
- Re: Can knowledge be wrong? Daan de Koning 05:33:07 8/18/99 (21)
- Re: Can knowledge be wrong? Richard 17:09:09 8/24/99 (7)
- The Irony of Meaning Daan de Koning 17:21:23 8/25/99 (3)
- Re: The Irony of Meaning Richard 19:52:35 8/26/99 (2)
- Re: The Irony of Meaning Daan de Koning 10:08:23 8/27/99 (1)
- Re: The Irony of Meaning Richard 14:47:44 8/28/99 (0)
- Can knowledge be wrong? The Meaning of Irony 19:01:15 8/24/99 (2)
- They didn't really sign up ... honest! Martyn R Jones 19:05:48 8/24/99 (1)
- :-))))))))))))))))))))) Kees de Vos 17:37:10 8/25/99 (0)
- Wrong, untrue, incorrect or out of context Martyn R Jones 08:42:16 8/18/99 (12)
- Re: Wrong, untrue, incorrect or out of context Daan de Koning 18:26:41 8/18/99 (11)
- Re: Wrong, untrue, incorrect or out of context Reilly Atkinson 00:33:04 8/20/99 (10)
- the truth, the only truth and nothing but KM Daan de Koning 05:20:16 8/20/99 (9)
- Re: the truth, the only truth and nothing but KM Reilly Atkinson 22:08:42 8/23/99 (8)
- Re: the truth, the only truth and nothing but KM Daan de Koning 04:50:14 8/24/99 (7)
- Re: there are exceptions (small fish eating the bigger fish) Kees de Vos 17:53:26 8/25/99 (0)
- Less is More Martyn R Jones 12:16:12 8/24/99 (5)
- Re: Less is More Reilly Atkinson 19:55:59 8/26/99 (4)
- Re: Less is More Richard 07:29:03 8/29/99 (3)
- Re: Less is More Reilly Atkinson 20:25:28 8/29/99 (2)
- Re: Less is More Richard 15:00:08 8/31/99 (1)
- Re: Less is More Reilly Atkinson 16:05:02 9/01/99 (0)
- Re: knowledge transferrence by writing Boris 11:55:11 8/02/99 (3)
- Re: knowledge transferrence by writing Kees de Vos 14:15:36 8/02/99 (2)
- Re: knowledge transferrence by writing Boris 16:25:27 8/02/99 (1)
- Re: knowledge transferrence by writing Kees de Vos 19:16:40 8/02/99 (0)
- Knowledge can not be transferred, but can be replicated. Kees de Vos 09:54:40 8/02/99 (15)
- Re: Knowledge can not be transferred, but can be replicated. Boris 11:42:51 8/02/99 (3)
- For Martyn, Reilly and Boris. - only People make knowledge John Bardos 18:22:35 8/06/99 (2)
- Re: For Martyn, Reilly and Boris. - only People make knowledge boris 07:43:45 8/10/99 (0)
- Re: For Martyn, Reilly and Boris. - only People make knowledge Reilly Atkinson 00:09:12 8/10/99 (0)
- Re: Knowledge can not be transferred, but can be replicated. Martyn R Jones 11:18:45 8/02/99 (10)
- Re: Knowledge can not be transferred, but can be replicated. Kees de Vos 13:47:49 8/02/99 (9)
- Re: Knowledge can not be transferred, but can be replicated. Reilly Atkinson 19:56:17 8/02/99 (8)
- Re: Knowledge can not be transferred, but can be replicated. Richard 21:09:34 8/02/99 (7)
- Re: Knowledge can not be transferred, but can be replicated. Reilly Atkinson 19:13:12 8/10/99 (0)
- Re: Knowledge can not be transferred, but can be replicated. Kees de Vos 05:16:39 8/03/99 (5)
- Replicatable but not Transferable - Tales from the Linguistic Soup Kitchen Martyn R Jones 07:37:24 8/03/99 (4)
- Re: addition on Learning Kees de Vos 07:37:47 8/04/99 (0)
- Re: Replicatable but not Transferable - Tales from the Linguistic Soup Kitchen Boris 07:06:05 8/04/99 (2)
- Knowledge Hoarding and the Rise & Fall of Empire Martyn R Jones 17:29:17 8/04/99 (0)
- Re: Replicatable but not Transferable - Tales from the Linguistic Soup Kitchen Martyn R Jones 17:18:48 8/04/99 (0)
- Re: Explicit - Knowledge a description of presentation? John Bardos 18:21:08 7/27/99 (0)
- Re: Explicit - Knowledge a description of presentation? Kees de Vos 10:39:10 7/27/99 (2)
- Re: Explicit - Knowledge a description of presentation? Boris 08:45:28 7/30/99 (1)
- Re: Explicit - Knowledge a description of presentation? Kees de Vos 19:29:30 7/30/99 (0)
- Re: Knowledge vs. Information John Tieso 08:58:30 7/27/99 (6)
- Explicit Knowledge???? no such thing. John Bardos 15:14:07 7/28/99 (2)
- Knowledge=information=data Lauri Gröhn 15:35:08 7/28/99 (1)
- Re: Knowledge=information=data John Bardos 15:50:46 7/28/99 (0)
- Seeing is not remembering Lauri Gröhn 15:06:55 7/27/99 (2)
- Re: Seeing is not remembering John Tieso 08:35:24 7/30/99 (0)
- Re: Seeing is not remembering Kees de Vos 17:15:57 7/27/99 (0)
- Re: Knowledge vs. Information Sogo Bolumole 06:32:30 7/27/99 (20)
- Re: Knowledge vs. Information Reilly Atkinson 16:02:55 7/27/99 (14)
- Re: Knowledge vs. Information Sogo Bolumole 07:59:51 7/28/99 (11)
- Re: Knowledge vs. Information Reilly Atkinson 15:26:07 7/28/99 (10)
- Re: Knowledge vs. Information Kees de Vos 20:21:56 7/30/99 (4)
- Re: Knowledge vs. Information Reilly Atkinson 15:39:28 8/01/99 (3)
- Re: Knowledge vs. Information Martyn R Jones 04:52:30 8/02/99 (1)
- Re: Knowledge vs. Information Reilly Atkinson 15:15:55 8/02/99 (0)
- Re: Knowledge vs. Information Kees de Vos 18:29:49 8/01/99 (0)
- New priests? Lauri Gröhn 17:57:06 7/28/99 (3)
- Re: New priests? Martyn R Jones 04:54:32 7/29/99 (1)
- Re: New priests? Lauri Grohn 05:23:29 7/29/99 (0)
- Re: New priests? Reilly Atkinson 19:07:56 7/28/99 (0)
- Re: Knowledge vs. Information john Bardos 15:41:55 7/28/99 (0)
- The history of date/information differentiation? Lauri Gröhn 16:44:54 7/27/99 (1)
- Re: The history of date/information differentiation? Reilly Atkinson 14:15:36 7/28/99 (0)
- Re: Knowledge vs. Information Lauri Grohn 08:12:53 7/27/99 (4)
- Re: Knowledge vs. Information Sogo bolumole 08:17:36 7/28/99 (0)
- Useless to what end? Kees de Vos 09:50:26 7/27/99 (2)
- Re: Useless to what end? Lauri Gröhn 14:41:17 7/27/99 (1)
- Re: Useless to what end? Kees de Vos 17:13:07 7/27/99 (0)
- Re: Knowledge vs. Information P. Richard Hansen 16:26:58 7/26/99 (0)
- Re: Knowledge vs. Information John Bardos 12:03:03 7/26/99 (1)
- Re: Knowledge vs. Information Kees de Vos 03:52:44 7/27/99 (0)
Click Here to Post Follow Up in New Forums
Download Our Articles and Interviews
[Guru Interviews] [Real Time Enterprise Business Processes] [IT Users Motivation] [IT Users Commitment] [Commitment and Motivation] [Inquiring Organizations] [Social Influences] [Customer Relationship Management] [Supply Chain Management] [IT Adoption and Utilization] [Managing and Measuring Knowledge Assets] [The Real Competitive Advantage] [Why IT and KM Systems Fail] [Myths About Expertise Management]
[How 'Best Practices' Become 'Worst Practices'] [Beyond Information Ecology to Knowledge Ecosystems] [Knowledge Exchanges and Social Networks] [Why Expert Systems Aren't Enough]
[KM for E-Business Performance]
[Does KM=IT? Not!]
[Other Articles and Interviews]
About BRINT | News About BRINT | Help & FAQs | Users Guide | Advertise
Make BRINT your Start Page | | Link to BRINT | Submit Articles
Terms of Use | Privacy | © Copyright 1994-2007, BRINT Institute, New York, USA