World Leading Hi-Tech Research Defining World Leading Risk Management & Risk Analytics Practices Projects
Goldman Sachs
JP Morgan
Wall Street Hedge Funds
Princeton Quant Presentations
Model Risk Management
SR11-7 & OCC2011-12
Research
Future of Finance
Bayesian vs. VaR
Markov Chain Monte Carlo Models
Cyber Finance
Future of Risk
Cyber Risk
Bitcoin Protocol
Current Research Projects at www.FinRM.org. Below: Historical Archive of Prior Research, Intelligence, and, Analysis Tools. |
|
Overview of the Personal Construction Theory
"Ultimately a man sets the measure of his own freedom and his own bondage by the level at which he chooses to establish his convictions." Personal Construction Theory: A Quick Synopsis
The key message of the Personal Construction Theory is that the world is 'perceived' by a person in terms of whatever 'meaning' that person applies to it and the person has the freedom to choose a different 'meaning' of whatever he or she wants. In other words, as suggested by George Kelly, the original proponent of the theory, the person has the 'freedom to choose' the meaning that one prefers or likes. He called this alternative constructivism. In simple words, the person is capable of applying alternative constructions (meanings) to any events in the past, present or future. The person is not a prisoner of one's 'biography or past' and could liberate oneself from the misery of 'miserable' events if one desires by reconstruing (reinterpreting and redefining) them. The theory rejects the existing schism between affect, cognition, and action and recommends that they be construed together for developing a fuller understanding of human behavior.
The following excerpts from various sources provide some 'flavor' of PCT.
PCT attempts to explain "Why man does what he does" (Kelly 1955). It is a theory about "how the human process flows, how it strives in new directions as well as in old, and how it may dare for the first time to reach into the depths of newly perceived dimensions." (Kelly cited in Fransella 1995).
"The person's processes are psychologically channelized by the ways in which he anticipate events". The subject is the process... the individual is essentially a behaving organism and doesn't need an external 'push' or 'pull' to get into motion. The processes include those of our self-definition and our relationships with others, as well as the tasks at hand (Kelly 1955).
George Kelly, the original proponent of PCT suggested that PCT is based on the model of man-the-scientist (1955). Within this model,
Constructs are "transparent patterns or templets which he creates and then attempts to fit over the realities of which the world is composed... Patterns that are tentatively tried for size... Ways of construing the world... Constructs are used for prediction of things to come, and the world keeps rolling along and revealing these predictions to be either correct or misleading. This fact provides the basis for revision of constructs and, eventually, of whole construction systems."
- the individual creates his or her own ways of seeing the world in which he lives; the world does not create them for him;
- (s)he builds constructs and tries them on for size;
- the constructs are sometimes organized into systems, group of constructs which embody subordinate and superordinate relationships;
- the same events can often be viewed in the light of two or more systems, yet the events do not belong to any system; and
- the individual's practical systems have particular foci and limited ranges of convenience.
Kelly suggested that the PCT was based on the philosophy of constructive alternativism: "We assume that all of our present interpretations of the universe are subject to revision or replacement... There are always some alternative constructions available to choose among in dealing with the world." Bannister (1981) later noted that: "Constructive alternativism argues for an open society in which the pursuit of alternatives is central to the way in which we live. Political doctrines favoring authoritarian forms of social structure require the acceptance of indisputable truths, indisputable 'realities.'"
Kelly's observation about determinism and man's free will is summed up in his following words: "He is not the victim of the pie, but of his notions of etiquette under which the pie cutting has been subsumed.... Man, to the extent that he is able to construe his circumstances, can find for himself freedom from their domination... Man can also enslave himself with his own ideas and then win his freedom by reconstruing his life. Ultimately a man sets the measure of his own freedom and his own bondage by the level at which he chooses to establish his convictions."
PCT doesn't ignore the relevance of the social context and the constraints imposed by it on personal construction: "But to believe that man is the author of his destiny is not to deny that he may be tragically limited by circumstances. I saw too many unfortunate youngsters, some of them literally starving in that depression-ridden dust bowl, for me not to be aware of their tragic limitations. Clearly there were many things they might have liked to do that circumstances would not permit. But, nevertheless, this is not to say that they were victims of circumstances. However, much there was denied them there was still an infinity of possibilities open to them. The task was to generate the imagination needed to envision those possibilities" (cited in Fransella 1995).
The contrast between the individual reality, social reality and shared reality is implied in the following distinctions noted by Kelly.
Individuality: "persons differ from each other in their construction of events."
Communality: "to the extent one person employs a construction of experience which is similar to that employed by another, his psychological processes are similar to those of the other person."
Socialty: "to the extent that one person construes the construction processes of another, he may play a role in a social process involving the other person."
Over the last 40 years, the theory has found its home in the areas of artificial intelligence, education, human computer interaction, and human learning, and is gradually gaining ground in the sociological disciplines. Of particular interest is the emphasis of the theory that communality (the social reality) and individuality (the personal reality) need to be considered together for developing an understanding of the psychological processes.
Other Resouces for Personal Construction Theory
- Business Applications of Repertory Grid (Book by Dr. Valerie Stewart)
- Preface to the New Edition
- Chapter 1: Finding out about people
- Chapter 2: Construct elicitation
- Chapter 3: Laddering
- Chapter 4: Choosing elements
- Chapter 5: Full grid
- Chapter 6: Analysis of grid data
- Chapter 7: Before you begin
- George Kelly: Biographical Notes and Bibliography of His Works
- Twelve issues for Cognitive Science (Norman)
- What is Personal Construct Psychology (PCP)?
- A Short Introduction to PCP (Scheer)
- What is Personal Construct Therapy? (Oades)
- Suggestions about Taking Off on Studies Based in Constructivism (Mancuso) "Personal construct psychology assumes an approach to knowledge -- both the knowledge of the investigator and the knowledge of the target of the investigation -- which differs sharply from the concepts of knowledge which prevailed when those statistical and metric methods were developed."
- Existing Schism in the 'Construal' of Personal Construct Psychology (Cromwell) Kelly's legacy has resulted in two distinct streams of research building on the PCP: the qualitative "narrative" group and the quantitative rep grid following. It has been noted by Kelly, and some other PCP researchers, that the essence of his theory cannot be captured by pure methodological rigor. For a fuller realization of the PCP, one needs to reflect: 'where the twain shall meet.'
- Using Personal Construct Theory in Careers Education and Guidance (Beven)
- NAPCN 96: Forty Years of PCP: Achievements and Directions: Abstracts
- Kelly's "Geometry of Psychological Space" and its Significance for Cognitive Modeling (Shaw & Gaines) An overview of the key issues relevant to PCP, explanation of the 'construct' and 'repertory grid' with illustrations. It expresses PCP as an "intensional logic describing the cognitive processes of anticipatory agents."
- The Collective Stance in Modeling Expertise in Individuals and Organizations (Gaines)
- Repertory Hypergrids: An Application to Clinical Practice Guidelines (Madigan et al.)
- Experience with the Learning Web (Shaw & Gaines)
- The Construct Psychology Centre at the University of Huddersfield, England
- KSI: Publications
- Knowledge Science Institute's Papers on Knowledge Acquisition and Representation (Personal Construct Psychology)
- Papers on Constructionism: Application of PCT in Education
- A Learning Model for Forecasting the Future of Information Technology (Gaines & Shaw)
- Positive Feedback Processes Underlying the Formation of Expertise (Gaines)
- Distributed Knowledge Modeling through the World Wide Web. Mildred L. G. Shaw and Brian R. Gaines
- Distributed Concept Mapping Collaboration using Java (Flores-Mindez)
- Comparing Constructions through the Web (Shaw & Gaines) Technology for Collaborative Learning on the Internet
- Notes on Personal Construct Psychology and the Repertory Grid (Shaw & Gaines 1990)
- Comparing Conceptual Structures: Consensus, Conflict, Correspondence and Contrast (Shaw & Gaines) Reference to Repertory Grids and Socio Grids.
- Concept Maps as Hypermedia Components (Gaines & Shaw)
- Knowledge Acquisition Tools based on Personal Construct Psychology (Gaines & Shaw)
- Foundations for the Learning Web (Gaines, Norrie & Shaw)
- Cognitive Processes in Artificial Intelligence (CPSC 679) Summary of Readings related to Personal Construct Theory
- Australian Personal Construct Newsletters Newsletter of the Personal Construct Psychology Research Group at University of Wollongong
- Personal Construct Psychology References Database
- An Internet Ancillary to PSYCHOLOGY 4th edition by Henry Gleitman 19 Chapters in Five Sections on Action, Cognition, Social Behavior, Development, and Individual Differences
- Cognitive Processes in Artificial Inteligence (Summary of Readings)
- WebGrid: Knowledge Elicitation and Modeling on the Web (Shaw & Gaines) "This article reports on experience in moving a highly interactive application, that of repertory grid elicitation and modeling, from personal computers to World-Wide Web servers to make it widely available on a platform-independent basis." Illustration of the use of the WebGrid is provided by using a context of a couple choosing a home from the selection offered by the realtor.
- Comparing Constructions through the Web (Shaw & Gaines) This paper illustrates the applications of WebGrid. It describes the "use of construct elicitation, modeling and comparison services on the World-Wide Web to enable collaborative learners to understand one another's constructs." A copy of this paper is also available at http://www-cscl95.indiana.edu/cscl95/shaw.html.
- Comparing Constructions through the Web "This article describes the use of construct elicitation, modeling and comparison services on the World-Wide Web to enable collaborative learners to understand one another's constructs. "
- Porting Interactive Applications to the Web (Gaines)
- Journal of Constructivist Psychology
- European Personal Construct Association
- Italian PCP Association: Links
- PCP List Server
- Modelling Cognitive Aspects of Complex Control Tasks (Ph.D. Dissertation of A. Simon Grant)
- A Study on Knowledge Based System Development for Preliminary Hull Form Design Dissertation on Knowledge Based Systems (U. of Tokyo)
- Was Ist Die Psychologie Der Persönlichen Konstrukte (PPK)? (German)
- Psicología de Los Constructos Personales (Spanish)
- PCT and Conceptual Graphs
- More WWW Sites with References to Kelly and Personal Constructs
- WWW Sites with References to Kelly and Repertory Grid Technique
- Cognition in Strategic Management (Bibliography)
- Books Specifically Devoted to PCP
- Representation of Organisational Knowledge for Requirements Analysis and Specification Using Cognitive Mapping (Project Summary)
- Development of Intelligent Interface for Tax Databases (Swigger & Michaelsen)
- Cognitive Science and Philosophy of Mind: Resources
- Constructivism: Resources (Martin Ryder)
- Learning Theories
- Directories of Psychology and Cognitive Sciences
- Resources for Psychology and Cognitive Sciences on the Internet
- Psychology Resources(Upper St. Clair School District)
- Objective and Essentialist, Subjective and Relativist Epistemologies: Nomothetic vs. Idiographic
- Guidelines for Knowledge Extraction
- Knowledge Acquisition Tools
- Trainer Notes: Cognitive Mapping Techniques
- Some Observations On The Use Of Scaling Methods In Knowledge Elicitation
- Teaching Repertory Grid Concepts for Knowledge Acquisition in Expert Systems--An Interactive Approach
- Breaching the Qualitative/Quantitative Divide: Repertory Grid Analysis with SPSS Princals (Stephen K Tagg)
Kelly's Repertory Grid:
Software Programs and Related ArticlesThe following information pertains to PC-compatible packages only. For macintosh compatible packages, please check out the links on this page under Other Tools for Repgrid Analysis
PC-Compatible Programs Available from the Authors
* OmniGrid by Ken Sewell
There are two versions of OMNIGRID available, depending on what kind of machine one wishes to run it on.
OMNIGRID 3.0 (the Macintosh version) requires HyperCard 2.0 and about 2 mg. of memory. It has been fully documented and the on-line help system has been implemented.
OMNIGRID-PC, an MS DOS version, can be obtained directly from Dr. Ken Sewell, Department of Psychology, University of North Texas, Denton, TX 76203 [sewellk@unt.edu], probably on a, more or less, cost recovery basis.
All versions of OMNIGRID are currently in the public domain, and further information about them can be found in the following publications:
Sewell, K.W., Adams-Webber, J., Mitterer, J.O. & Cromwell, R.L. (1992). Computerized repertory grids. International Journal of Personal Construct Psychology, 5, 1-23.
Sewell, K.W., Mitterer, J.O., Adams-Webber, J., & Cromwell, R.L. (1991). OMNIGRID-PC: A new development in computerized repertory grids. International Journal of Personal Construct Psychology , 4, 175-192.
Mitterer, J.O. & Adams-Webber, J. (1988). OMNIGRID: A program for the construction, administration and analysis of repertory grids. In J. C. Mancuso & M. L. G. Shaw (Eds.), Cognition and personal structure: Computer access and analysis (pp. 89-103). New York: Praeger.
* PC-Grid by April Metzler
April Metzler's e-mail, for PCGRID, is aem3@lehigh.edu and address is:
College of Education, Dept. of Counseling Psychology, School of Psychology and Special Education, Mountaintop Campus, 111 Research Drive, Bethlehem, Pennsylvania 18015-4792.
PC-Compatible Programs Downloadable from the Internet
BASIC Repgrid Program
http://ksi.cpsc.ucalgary.ca/PCP/1994Q1/0007.html
Circumgrids
Information available at:
http://www.york.ac.uk/inst/ctipsych/web/CTI/DirTxt/reviews/circum.html
C-Map (For Concept Mapping)
Information at:
http://utto1031.to.utwente.nl/artikel1/httoc.htm
Downloadable from:
gopher://oldal.mannlib.cornell.edu:9570/40/misc/CMap_2.0.hqx
Grid Analysis Package (GAP)
http://midas.ac.uk/sapi/GAP.html Grid Analysis Package (GAP) consists of several programs for the analysis of data obtained by the repertory grid technique, which is used for measuring the content and structure of the cognitive system.
G-Pack
http://www.psyc.uow.edu.au/pcp/gpack.html Computer Program for the Elicitation & Analysis of Repertory Grids The program is written by Richard Bell, University of Melbourne, and distributed by the Personal Construct Group, Department of Psychology, University of Wollongong.
Ingrid Thought Processor
http://homepages.ihug.co.nz/~income/tutorial.htm
Repertory Grids (Chris Evans)
http://psyctc.sghms.ac.uk/grids/default.htm
WebGrid: WWW PCP Server: Accessible for interactive use online at:
http://tiger.cpsc.ucalgary.ca/WebGrid/WebGrid.html
Decision Explorer (Earlier called: Graphics COPE; For Capturing, Presenting and Analyzing Cognitive Maps)
http://www.scotnet.co.uk/banxia/gcmain.html
Relevant Articles, etc.
An excellent review of computer packages for grid analysis and elicitation was presented by Sewell et al in the International Journal of Personal Construct Psychology, 1992, Volume5, No1, pp. 1-23.
Michael Bringmann's article "Computer based methods for the analysis and interpretation of personal construct systems". In Neimeyer, R.A., & Neimeyer, G.J. (Eds). (1992). Advances in Personal Construct Psychology, Vol 2. Greenwich, Connecticut: JAI Press.
For developing such systems one might want to check Mildred Shaw's work, in particular: Shaw, M.L.G. (1980). On becoming a personal scientist: Interactive computer elicitaton of personal models of the world. London: Academic Press.
Richard C. Bell, "Analytic Issues in the Use of Repertory Grid Technique," in Advances in PCP (1990) vol 1 pp. 25-48.
University of Wollongong has a Bibliographic data base with some articles on grids at:
http://www.psyc.uow.edu.au/pcp/
Software Comparisons including Repgrid Packages are accessible at:
http://qsr.latrobe.edu.au/Resource/SoftwareComparison.txt
Other Tools for Repgrid Analysis
- Enquire Within and the Repertory Grid Interview
- Repertory Hypergrids: An Application to Clinical Practice Guidelines
- WebGrid: a WWW PCP Server "WebGrid is a specialist server on WWW that uses techniques from personal construct psychology (PCP) to allow individuals to make explicit their mental models of a domain... WebGrid uses Kelly's repertory grid techniques to elicit personal constructs about a set of elements relevant to the domain of interest."
- Repertory Grids (Chris Evans)Includes an Introduction to repertory grids, and software packages INGRID, CIRCUMGRIDS, and OMNIGRID. Also see Introduction to Grids and Grids. Also see Chris Evans' note on Multidimensional Scaling. Also, see his Psychotherapy Section for some Statistical and psychometric utilities.
- Everything on Concept Mapping
- C-Map (For Concept Mapping)
- Graphics COPE (Capturing, Presenting and Analyzing Cognitive Maps) Software for cognitive mapping of rep grids and related paper: Getting Started with Cognitive Mapping (Ackermann, Eden & Cropper) and its relevance to PCT.
Terms of Use | Privacy | © Copyrights 1994-Current
Global Risk Management Network, LLC, New York 14852-4892, U.S.A.